Best Crime Games for PS5 & PS4

Grand Theft Auto V, Red Dead Redemption 2 and Yakuza 0 lead the best crime games on PS5 and PS4: 16 hand-picked gangster epics, heist shooters and noir thrillers, ranked by overall quality and weighed against what players actually say, not critic scores alone. Every pick makes crime the game itself, from running a Los Santos heist crew to climbing Japan's underworld; action games that only borrow a criminal backdrop are left off. Five picks come with PS Plus Extra or Premium.

Updated Oct 19, 2026

Top Picks

Discover Games

16 games found

1Grand Theft Auto V (PlayStation®5)
Best overall

Grand Theft Auto V (PlayStation®5)

4.5(956,165)Metacritic 922013~74 h playtime
PS5PS4PCAdventure · Action
Co-op: 8modern
GreatReview analysis

Overall, player feedback for Grand Theft Auto V on PlayStation 5 is overwhelmingly positive, with many praising the game for its rich storytelling, expansive open world, and the freedom it offers players. However, there are notable frustrations with the online mode, particularly concerning hackers, account management issues, and the game's economy.

Why it's here: The best crime game on PlayStation, and the most-rated pick here by a distance. Three criminals share one Los Santos, and you switch between gunman, driver and lookout in the middle of a heist, a trick nobody has copied since. The recurring complaint in Steam reviews is GTA Online: hackers, grind and high in-game prices. It holds 4.46 from more than 950,000 player ratings and is rated Mature. Buy it for the campaign and treat Online as optional.

Guide

GTA 5 vs Red Dead Redemption 2GTA 5 vs Red Dead Redemption 2 compared: how Rockstar's chaotic crime sandbox and its slow-burn western differ on story, pace, online, length and scores.

See full details
2Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

4.8(476,339)Metacritic 962018~21 h playtime
PS4PCAdventure · Action
PS+ Extrawestern
GreatReview analysis

Overall, players overwhelmingly praise "Red Dead Redemption 2" for its breathtaking visuals, immersive story, and engaging gameplay, consistently describing it as one of the best games they've experienced. However, some critiques surface about the online mode and certain gameplay mechanics, indicating there's room for improvement. Despite these criticisms, the general consensus is that the game is a masterpiece that players would recommend strongly.

Why it's here: The strongest story on this list. You ride with Arthur Morgan through one outlaw gang's slow collapse, across a frontier whose detail and realism players single out above everything else. Steam reviews keep returning to one caveat: slow travel and forced riding sequences that refuse to hurry. At 4.76 from about 476,000 player ratings it is the most-rated game here after GTA V, rated Mature 17+ and included with PS Plus Extra. If you have patience for a slow first act, start it tonight.

Guides

Red Dead Redemption 2 vs Red Dead RedemptionRed Dead Redemption 2 vs Red Dead Redemption compared on world, gunplay, story, length, frame rate and player ratings, with a verdict on which to play.

GTA 5 vs Red Dead Redemption 2GTA 5 vs Red Dead Redemption 2 compared: how Rockstar's chaotic crime sandbox and its slow-burn western differ on story, pace, online, length and scores.

See full details
3Yakuza 0
Best organized crime

Yakuza 0

4.8(22,000)Metacritic 852015~8 h playtime
PS4PCFighting · Action
crime
GreatReview analysis

Overall, player feedback for Yakuza 0 is overwhelmingly positive, with many praising the engaging story, rich world-building, and diverse gameplay elements including mini-games. Some criticisms arise regarding grinding requirements for skill progression and technical issues on the PC version, but these are largely overshadowed by the game's strengths. Most players recommend it as a fantastic entry point into the Yakuza series, highlighting its captivating characters and immersive environments.

Why it's here: Start the Yakuza series here. In 1988 Japan you play two future legends, and the game swings from brutal street brawls to karaoke and a real-estate empire without losing its footing. The recurring complaint in Steam reviews is grind-heavy skill progression. Its 4.81 from 22,000 player ratings is the highest score of any Mature-rated pick on this list. Push past the first hour: players consistently name it the ideal entry point to the series.

Guide

Yakuza Games in OrderEvery Yakuza and Like a Dragon game in chronological and release order, where to start, how Judgment and the spin-offs fit, and what players say to trim.

See full details
4Mafia: Definitive Edition

Mafia: Definitive Edition

4.4(28,000)Metacritic 782020~10 h playtime
PS4PCAction
crime
GreatReview analysis

Overall player feedback for Mafia: Definitive Edition is overwhelmingly positive, with many players praising its gripping story, immersive setting, and stunning graphics. However, some critics point out issues with the driving mechanics, repetitive gameplay, and a feeling that the experience could have been enriched further. Despite these criticisms, the game remains a beloved remake that appeals to both newcomers and long-time fans of the franchise.

Why it's here: Pick this when you want a crime film you can steer. A Depression-era cab driver falls in with a crime family in a ground-up remake of the 2002 original, told as linear chapters with no sandbox padding. Steam reviews praise the story and atmosphere and single out the driving as the frustration. It sits at 4.41 from 28,000 player ratings, rated Mature 17+. Clear it over a long weekend and take it on its own scripted terms.

See full details
5L.A. Noire
Best noir

L.A. Noire

4.7(10,550)Metacritic 832011~7 h playtime
PS4PCAction · Adventure
MixedReview analysis

Overall, player feedback on L.A. Noire is highly polarized, with many praising its unique storytelling, engaging gameplay mechanics, and atmospheric setting; yet, numerous players express frustration over its technical issues and the requirement of third-party DRM. Despite the criticisms, a significant number of players regard it as a masterpiece in detective gaming.

Why it's here: For solving crimes instead of committing them, this is the one. You work 1947 Los Angeles case by case as a detective, and the key evidence is a suspect's motion-captured face in the interrogation room. Reception in Steam reviews is polarized, and the loudest friction belongs to that PC release: a mandatory third-party account and a 30 FPS lock. On PlayStation it holds 4.66 from about 10,500 player ratings, rated Mature. No other pick here is built around interrogation.

Guide

L.A. Noire vs JudgmentL.A. Noire vs Judgment compared on investigation depth, combat, side content and player ratings, with a clear pick for which detective game to play first.

See full details
6Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption

4.7(41,064)Metacritic 952010~6 h playtime
PS5PS4PCAction
western
GreatReview analysis

Overall player feedback on "Red Dead Redemption" is overwhelmingly positive, highlighting the game's engaging narrative, memorable characters, and immersive world, even years after its original release. Many players appreciate the emotional depth of John Marston's story and the improved performance on modern consoles. However, there are some criticisms regarding the game's age and certain mechanics that feel outdated compared to its sequel.

Why it's here: John Marston's story, and the reason to stay in the series after the sequel. A former outlaw is forced by federal agents to hunt down the gang he once rode with, across the American West and Mexico, with the Undead Nightmare expansion included. Steam reviews praise the emotional weight of the story, and the recurring complaint is mechanics that feel dated next to Red Dead Redemption 2. It holds 4.71 from about 41,000 player ratings, rated Mature 17+. Finish the sequel first, then come here for Marston's side of it.

Guide

Red Dead Redemption 2 vs Red Dead RedemptionRed Dead Redemption 2 vs Red Dead Redemption compared on world, gunplay, story, length, frame rate and player ratings, with a verdict on which to play.

See full details
7Sleeping Dogs

Sleeping Dogs

4.6(33,490)Metacritic 762014~6 h playtime
PS4PCAdventure · Action
crime
GreatReview analysis

Overall, players have provided overwhelmingly positive feedback for Sleeping Dogs, praising its engaging story, fun combat mechanics, and the vibrant open world setting. However, some players noted issues with outdated gameplay mechanics and limited activities in the open world.

Why it's here: The sleeper of the list. You play an undercover cop sinking into a Hong Kong triad, and the fights are hand-to-hand brawls that owe more to martial-arts cinema than to the genre's usual gunplay. The recurring gripe in Steam reviews is outdated mechanics and limited activities in the open world. The store rating is firm all the same: 4.56 from about 33,500 players, rated Mature. Choose it over the bigger sandboxes when you want a story that wastes none of your time.

See full details
8HITMAN 3

HITMAN 3

4.4(57,535)Metacritic 832021~6 h playtime
PS5PS4PCAction
modern
MixedReview analysis

Player feedback for HITMAN 3 is largely positive, with many praising its level design, freedom of play, and rewarding gameplay. However, there are notable criticisms regarding its confusing pricing model and mandatory online requirements, which detract from the overall experience for some users.

Why it's here: One target, one clockwork level, and dozens of ways in. Each mission leaves the disguises, routines and staged accidents to you, which is why players call out its replayability. Steam reviews praise the level design and aim their anger at the storefront: a confusing DLC pricing model and a mandatory online connection. It carries 4.39 from about 57,500 player ratings, rated Mature 17+. Work out which edition you own first, then replay the opening level until the routes click.

See full details
9PAYDAY 2: CRIMEWAVE EDITION
Best heist

PAYDAY 2: CRIMEWAVE EDITION

4.3(38,000)Metacritic 792013
PS4PCShooter · Arcade
crime
GreatReview analysis

Overall, player feedback on PAYDAY 2: CRIMEWAVE EDITION is overwhelmingly positive, celebrating its engaging cooperative gameplay, vast content, and replayability, though criticism arises regarding the game's difficulty balancing and extensive DLC pricing. Many players highlight the fun experienced during heists, particularly when played with friends, while also expressing frustration about bugs and the game's dependence on DLC for full content access.

Why it's here: The heist pick, on one condition: bring friends. Four players case a job, choose loadouts and try to walk out quiet, one slip away from a firefight. Steam reviews agree the co-op is where it sings, and the recurring complaint is a heavy reliance on paid DLC to see the full game. At 4.3 from 38,000 player ratings it sits in the bottom three on this list by score, rated Mature. With a regular crew and a sale price it is the best pure heist loop here.

See full details
10Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth PS4 & PS5

Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth PS4 & PS5

4.7(16,416)2024~51 h playtime
PS5PS4PCRole Playing Games
PS+ Extramodern
MixedReview analysis

Player feedback for 'Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth' is polarized, with many praising its gameplay improvements, engaging side content, and nostalgic elements from earlier titles. However, numerous criticisms center on the story's pacing, reliance on grinding, and the controversial decision to lock certain features behind DLC. Overall, the reception highlights a strong contrast between enjoyment of mechanics and dissatisfaction with narrative execution.

Why it's here: The biggest swing on the list: the crime saga rebuilt as a turn-based RPG, sending an ex-yakuza from Japan to Hawaii with a full party. Steam reviews are polarized. The upgraded battle system and mini games draw real affection, and the recurring complaint is a drawn-out story with New Game Plus locked behind DLC. It holds 4.73 from about 16,400 player ratings, rated Mature 17+, and it is included with PS Plus Extra. Play it there, after Yakuza 0.

Guide

Yakuza Games in OrderEvery Yakuza and Like a Dragon game in chronological and release order, where to start, how Judgment and the spin-offs fit, and what players say to trim.

See full details
11WATCH_DOGS™

WATCH_DOGS™

4.5(66,893)Metacritic 772014~16 h playtime
PS4PCAdventure · Action
PS+ Extramodern
MixedReview analysis

Overall, player feedback for Watch_Dogs is largely positive, with significant appreciation for its unique hacking mechanics, immersive storyline, and atmospheric setting. However, criticisms about technical issues and repetitive gameplay mechanics also emerged, leading to a varied experience for players.

Why it's here: Chicago itself is the weapon here. Traffic lights, phones and cameras are one tap from becoming a trap as you run a personal vendetta through a wired city. Steam reviews rate the hacking and the story well, and the consistent knock is clunky driving. It sits at 4.45 from nearly 67,000 player ratings, rated Mature, and it is included with PS Plus Extra. As a subscription download it is an easy evening's test of whether the hacking loop is for you.

Guide

Watch Dogs vs Watch Dogs 2Watch Dogs vs Watch Dogs 2 compared on world, gameplay, story, performance and length, with Game-Scout player ratings and which one to start on PS Plus Extra.

See full details
12WATCH_DOGS® 2

WATCH_DOGS® 2

4.4(187,549)Metacritic 792016~17 h playtime
PS4PCAdventure · Action
PS+ Extramodern
MixedReview analysis

Player feedback on Watch Dogs 2 is sharply divided, with many praising the fun and engaging gameplay, especially in the context of hacking and the open world. However, numerous complaints about severe graphical issues, bugs, and performance problems have led to frustration among some players, overshadowing the positive experiences.

Why it's here: The Watch_Dogs to download first. You play Marcus Holloway, a young hacker who joins DedSec to expose a surveillance system across the San Francisco Bay Area, mixing stealth, action and hacking however you like. Steam reviews are sharply divided, and the recurring complaint is technical: graphical glitches and bugs on that PC release. On PlayStation it holds 4.37 from about 187,500 player ratings, the third-most on this list, rated Mature and included with PS Plus Extra. Start the series here if the first game's vendetta sounds too grim.

Guide

Watch Dogs vs Watch Dogs 2Watch Dogs vs Watch Dogs 2 compared on world, gameplay, story, performance and length, with Game-Scout player ratings and which one to start on PS Plus Extra.

See full details
13Saints Row IV: Re-Elected

Saints Row IV: Re-Elected

4.5(23,000)Metacritic 732013~3 h playtime
PS4PCAdventure · Action
sci-fi
GoodReview analysis

Overall, player feedback for Saints Row IV: Re-Elected is largely positive, with many players enjoying the humor, superpowers, and entertaining gameplay. However, criticisms arise regarding technical issues, inconsistent gameplay experiences, and a sense of deterioration compared to previous entries in the franchise.

Why it's here: When the genre needs to stop taking itself seriously, play this. A street-gang boss becomes US President, aliens invade, and superpowers turn the city into a playground: crime as outright parody. Steam reviews back the humour and the superpowers, and name technical issues and bugs as the price of admission. It holds 4.5 from 23,000 player ratings and is rated Mature, so the comedy is not for kids. Slot it between the heavy stories higher up this list.

See full details
14Mafia: The Old Country

Mafia: The Old Country

4.1(19,000)2025~16 h playtime
PS5PCAction · Adventure
crime
MixedReview analysis

Overall player feedback is mixed, with some praising the storytelling, character work, and visuals, while others criticize poor gameplay mechanics and lack of polish. The sentiment varies significantly among players, leading to polarized opinions that highlight both strong positives and serious flaws.

Why it's here: The newest mafia story on PlayStation. In 1900s Sicily you play Enzo Favara, climbing out of forced labor to swear an oath to the Torrisi crime family in a concise, story-led third-person adventure. PlayStation Store reviews are mixed: the acting and visuals earn real praise, and the recurring complaint is a slow start with dragging stealth sections. It holds 4.11 from 19,000 player ratings, rated Mature 17+, one hundredth above the lowest score here. Play Mafia: Definitive Edition first, and pick this up if you want more of the same.

See full details
15Mafia III: Definitive Edition

Mafia III: Definitive Edition

4.1(59,000)2020~1 h playtime
PS4PCAdventure · Action
crime
MixedReview analysis

Overall, player feedback on Mafia III: Definitive Edition is heavily polarized, with many praising its engaging story and atmosphere while criticizing its repetitive gameplay and numerous technical issues. While some players found the music and character development compelling, many others expressed frustration over the game's bugs and lack of identity compared to earlier titles in the Mafia series.

Why it's here: The most divisive pick, kept for its setting. No game here has a stronger sense of place than New Bordeaux, its 1968 stand-in for New Orleans, and Steam reviews praise the story and soundtrack without much argument. The same reviews are just as clear about the cost: a repetitive mission structure that turns into a grind. At 4.1 from 59,000 player ratings it is the lowest-rated game on this list, rated Mature. Wait for a deep sale and play it for the story missions.

See full details
16Sly 2: Band of Thieves™
Best for families

Sly 2: Band of Thieves™

4.9(9,599)Metacritic 882004
PS5PS4Adventure
PS+ Premiumfantasy

Why it's here: A statistical surprise: the highest player rating on this list belongs to the one game a ten-year-old can play. A master-thief raccoon and his crew run episodic heists, casing each target before the job. It has no review sentiment in our pipeline, so the evidence is the store score alone: 4.92 from about 9,600 player ratings, the fewest on this list, rated Everyone 10+ and included with PS Plus Premium. For a household, or anyone who wants crime without the grit, this is the pick.

See full details

Get the next list first

We publish new curated lists and guides every week. Drop your email and we will tell you when the next one lands.

Occasional updates only — unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy policy.

About Crime Games

Crime games put the player on the wrong side of the law: building a gangster empire, casing a heist, climbing the mafia ladder or working noir cases from inside the force. This list spans that full range on PS5 and PS4, from the sandbox chaos of Grand Theft Auto V and Saints Row IV to the scripted mob tragedies of Mafia: Definitive Edition, Mafia III and Mafia: The Old Country, PAYDAY 2's four-player robberies, Hitman 3's contract kills and L.A. Noire's interrogation-room detective work. Picks are ordered by overall quality, drawing on player ratings, critic reception and player reviews collected from Steam and the PlayStation Store, summarized on each game's page into what players consistently praise and consistently complain about. Five carry PS Plus value: Red Dead Redemption 2, Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth, Watch_Dogs and Watch_Dogs 2 on Extra, and Sly 2: Band of Thieves on Premium.

Curated by Ugur Saritepe. Rankings weigh aggregated player ratings and review sentiment collected from the stores each game is sold on — Steam and the PlayStation Store — with catalogue data from RAWG. How we rankPlayStation StoreSteamRAWG

Explore More Gaming Categories

Best Crime Games Compared

  • Grand Theft Auto V (PlayStation®5)
    Best overall★ 4.46 / 5

    Switches between three criminals mid-heist, so one robbery plays out from the gunman, the driver and the lookout at once.

  • Red Dead Redemption 2
    ★ 4.76 / 5PS Plus Extra

    Follows one outlaw gang's slow collapse at the death of the Wild West, told with obsessive period detail.

  • Yakuza 0
    Best organized crime★ 4.81 / 5

    Swings between brawls in neon-lit 1988 Japan and running a real-estate empire; the most-recommended starting point for the series.

  • Mafia: Definitive Edition
    ★ 4.41 / 5

    A scripted, linear rise-and-fall through a Depression-era crime family, remade from the 2002 original instead of a sandbox.

  • L.A. Noire
    Best noir★ 4.66 / 5

    Solves 1947 Los Angeles cases from the detective's side, reading motion-captured faces for lies in the interrogation room.

  • Red Dead Redemption
    ★ 4.71 / 5

    Sends a former outlaw after his old gang across the American West and Mexico, with Undead Nightmare included.

  • Sleeping Dogs
    ★ 4.56 / 5

    Plays an undercover cop losing himself in a Hong Kong triad, with martial-arts brawling in place of the usual gunplay.

  • HITMAN 3
    ★ 4.39 / 5

    Treats each target as a clockwork puzzle of disguises, routines and accidents inside intricate sandbox levels.

  • PAYDAY 2: CRIMEWAVE EDITION
    Best heist★ 4.3 / 5

    Runs four-player co-op robberies where one slipped mask turns a quiet job into a firefight.

  • Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth PS4 & PS5
    ★ 4.73 / 5PS Plus Extra

    Reworks the crime saga as a turn-based RPG, sending an ex-yakuza from Japan's streets to Hawaii with a full party.

  • WATCH_DOGS™
    ★ 4.45 / 5PS Plus Extra

    Makes a surveillance-wired Chicago the weapon, hacking traffic lights, phones and cameras instead of relying on guns and cars.

  • WATCH_DOGS® 2
    ★ 4.37 / 5PS Plus Extra

    Moves the hacking to the San Francisco Bay Area with a young DedSec crew and a looser mix of stealth and action.

  • Saints Row IV: Re-Elected
    ★ 4.5 / 5

    Cranks the gangster sandbox into science-fiction parody, handing a street-gang president superpowers against an alien invasion.

  • Mafia: The Old Country
    ★ 4.11 / 5

    Goes back to 1900s Sicily for one man's oath to the Torrisi crime family, told as a concise story.

  • Mafia III: Definitive Edition
    ★ 4.1 / 5

    Dismantles a 1968 New Orleans mob district by district, carried by its period soundtrack, story and setting.

  • Sly 2: Band of Thieves™
    Best for families★ 4.92 / 5PS Plus Premium

    A cartoon raccoon's episodic capers prove a heist game can skip the gritty underworld entirely.

Upcoming Crime games

  • Grand Theft Auto VI

    November 19, 2026PS5 · Xbox Series X/S

    The next Grand Theft Auto, and the obvious challenger to the game at the top of this list. It joins the ranking once it has player ratings.

  • Stranger Than Heaven

    January 15, 2027PS5 · Xbox Series X/S · PC

    A fifty-year crime saga across five cities and eras of modern Japan, from the studio behind Yakuza and Like a Dragon.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best crime game on PS5?
Grand Theft Auto V is the best crime game on PS5 and PS4, with Red Dead Redemption 2 close behind as a story-driven outlaw epic. Yakuza 0 completes the podium and leads the organized-crime side alongside Mafia: Definitive Edition.
What is the best open-world crime game?
Grand Theft Auto V leads for sandbox freedom and heists. Red Dead Redemption 2, Sleeping Dogs and Watch_Dogs offer distinct open-world takes: a Western outlaw epic, an undercover job inside Hong Kong's triads, and a hacked-out Chicago.
What are the best mafia and gangster games on PS5?
Mafia: Definitive Edition is the strongest mafia pick, a scripted rise-and-fall through a Depression-era crime family, with Mafia III: Definitive Edition moving the fight to 1968 New Orleans and Mafia: The Old Country, the newest entry, going back to 1900s Sicily. On the Japanese side, Yakuza 0 and Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth cover the gangster fantasy, and Infinite Wealth is included with PS Plus Extra.
Are there good heist games on PS5?
Yes. PAYDAY 2 is the best dedicated heist game here, built around four-player co-op robberies, and Hitman 3 delivers the assassination side of crime through intricate sandbox contracts. GTA V also features heist missions in both story and online modes.
Are any crime games suitable for kids?
Most crime games are rated Mature for violence and mature themes. The exception on this list is Sly 2: Band of Thieves, a cartoon master-thief platformer rated Everyone 10+, included with PS Plus Premium and the best family-friendly pick. Always check the ESRB rating on each game's detail page before buying for younger players.
Is GTA 6 on this list?
Not yet. Grand Theft Auto VI is scheduled for November 19, 2026 on PS5 and Xbox Series X/S, and it joins the ranking once it has player ratings to weigh. Until then Grand Theft Auto V stays the top pick.
How is this crime games list ranked?
This is an editorially curated list. Games are hand-picked for genuine crime gameplay, covering gangster, mafia, heist, noir and underworld experiences, and ordered by overall quality using player ratings and critic scores. Games that only use a crime backdrop without the gameplay are deliberately excluded.

Was this helpful?