Best Detective Games for PS5 & PS4

Why it's here: This is the definitive detective game and my pick for the top of the list. You play Cole Phelps, an LAPD detective in 1947 Los Angeles, working real cases — searching crime scenes for clues, chasing suspects, and reading faces in interrogations using motion-capture tech that still impresses. That actual detective work is the whole draw. The honest caveat: it's a 2017 release, so the driving and shooting between cases can feel dated and repetitive, and it needs a Rockstar account to play. Rated Mature, on PS Plus, 4.67 from nearly 10,000 players — the highest-rated big-budget detective game here. If you play one game off this list, make it this.

Why it's here: If you want the most acclaimed detective RPG ever made, start here. You're a wrecked, amnesiac detective piecing together a murder in a crumbling city — but there's no combat at all; every case beat is dialogue, skill checks, and arguing with the warring voices in your own head. The writing is why it's a masterpiece. The flip side is obvious: it's enormous and entirely reading, so if you want action you'll bounce off it. Rated Mature, on PS5 and PS4, 4.67 from 12,000 players — the most-rated game on this list. Essential if you like detective work that's all deduction and dialogue.

Why it's here: If you want actual detective work and not just a story about one, this is the best hands-on pick. From the Yakuza team, it has you tailing suspects, examining crime scenes and solving cases, then brawling through Kamurocho when things kick off. That mix of investigation and action makes it the best all-rounder of the bigger titles here. The downside is the usual Yakuza one: it's big and can sprawl. Rated Mature, 4.64 from 13,000 players. Easy to recommend if you want to do the sleuthing yourself with some action between cases.

Why it's here: A cornerstone of the genre and still one of the best cinematic detective stories on PlayStation. A branching crime thriller where you switch between several characters hunting a killer, and the hook is that your choices — and your failures — genuinely stick, with multiple endings to match. The tension and story are the draw. Worth knowing it's heavy on quick-time events rather than traditional gameplay, which won't be for everyone. Rated Mature and on PS Plus, so you may already have access. For a pure, gripping interactive detective story, it's hard to beat.

Why it's here: The Judgment sequel, and a sharper one. It keeps the investigate-then-fight loop of the first game but leans into a darker, more serious mystery, with school-set intrigue driving the case. If you liked Judgment, this is more of it, refined. Same caveat — it's long and packed with side content that can distract from the case — and you'll get more from it having played the first. Rated Mature, 4.6 from around 10,000 players. A strong second helping for anyone who wants meaty, hands-on detective work.

Why it's here: The purest deduction game here, and a strong contender for the single best on the list at 4.81. You board a long-lost ship where all sixty souls are dead, and using a pocket-watch that replays each person's final moment, you must work out every name and fate from clues alone. That puzzle — and the satisfaction of cracking it — is unmatched. Be warned it's genuinely hard and uncompromising, with stark 1-bit visuals that won't suit everyone. Rated Mature, on PS4, from around 1,400 players. If you want to feel like an actual detective solving a case with your own logic, nothing else comes close.

Why it's here: Three remastered classics in one, and the best courtroom detective work you can get. You investigate cases as rookie defence attorney Phoenix Wright, gather evidence, then take it to court to cross-examine witnesses and catch them in contradictions — that 'gotcha' moment of exposing a lie is the hook. The catch is it's a visual novel, so it's linear and story-on-rails rather than free investigation. Rated Teen, on PS4, 4.77 from 4,900 players — one of the highest-rated picks here, and great value at three games. A must if you love the courtroom side of detective fiction.

Why it's here: From Obsidian, this is the thinking person's historical murder mystery. You're an artist in 16th-century Bavaria investigating a string of killings across years, and the sting is that you rarely get certainty — your choices decide who's accused, and you live with being wrong. The hand-illuminated manuscript art and moral weight are why it's so admired. The honest note: it's slow, text-heavy and has no action, so it asks for patience. Rated Mature, on PS5 and PS4, 4.70 from around 950 players. A standout if you want a detective story where the deduction is moral, not mechanical.

Why it's here: For the Sherlock fantasy with real deduction, this is the pick. You play a young Holmes on a Mediterranean island, building cases by gathering clues and cross-referencing them yourself — crucially, the game lets you accuse the wrong person and never confirms you're right, so the detective work is genuinely on you. That open-ended investigation is the strength. The weakness is the padding: tacked-on combat and some rough edges around a great core. Rated Mature, on PS5 and PS4, 4.15 from 1,800 players. Worth it if you want to do the deducing instead of being walked through it.

Why it's here: A bit of a curveball, but it earns its place. This remastered classic is a film-noir mystery dressed in Day-of-the-Dead style — a hard-boiled detective story told through dialogue and inventory puzzles. The atmosphere and writing are why it's still loved. Be warned it's an old-school adventure game, so some puzzles are obtuse by modern standards and the pacing is slow. Rated Teen, 4.35 from 34,000 players. If you like your detective work noir and don't mind a classic point-and-click pace, it's well worth your time.

Why it's here: Quietly the highest-rated game on the whole list at 4.82. A supernatural casework adventure with sharp writing — you investigate urban legends one case at a time, following clues and branching dialogue to the truth. The writing and case structure are the reason to play. It's smaller and text-forward, so if you want action you'll be disappointed; this is reading and deduction. Rated Teen, from over 2,000 players. If you like methodical, story-driven detective work and don't need flashy gameplay, I'd bump it up your list.

Why it's here: The most RPG-flavoured detective game on the list. A supernatural-detective story from the Shin Megami Tensei universe set in a stylish historical Japan — you investigate and interrogate, then settle fights by summoning demons in real-time action combat. That blend of casework and RPG systems is what makes it stand out. The catch is the niche audience and a remaster that wraps an older design. Rated Mature, sitting high at 4.63 from around 1,100 players. A great pick if you want detective work with a fantasy-RPG twist.

Why it's here: For the cop-on-the-beat fantasy, this is the pick. Set in an '80s city, you patrol, respond to crimes and build cases from evidence, with a sandbox, procedurally generated feel so no two shifts play the same. That emergent policing is the appeal. It's a smaller production, so expect some rough edges over big-budget shine. Rated Teen, 4.3 from around 5,000 players. A good fit if you want the day-to-day detective grind — patrol, investigate, arrest — over a scripted story.

Why it's here: This is the family pick. An open-world LEGO game where you play an undercover cop chasing a crook across the city — light detective framing wrapped around the usual LEGO mix of platforming, collecting and slapstick humour. It's genuinely fun for kids and adults playing along. Don't expect real investigation; the "detective" part is mostly story dressing. Rated Everyone 10+ and on PS Plus Extra, 4.33 from 12,000 players. If you want something the whole family can enjoy off this list, this is the obvious one.

Why it's here: The most purely fun "detective" pick here. A short, funny point-and-click whodunit where you fill in the blanks of a case Mad-Libs style, with light puzzles and a charming deadpan tone. The writing and brevity are the appeal — you can finish it in an evening. That's also the catch: it's small and easy, not a deep investigation. Rated Everyone, 4.72 from a small but happy crowd. If you want something light, clever and low-stress to break up the heavier games here, start here.