Games Like Sea of Thieves on PS5 & PS4 (2026)

Overall player feedback for Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag is very positive, with many praising its immersive pirate gameplay, strong narrative, and naval combat mechanics, alongside some criticism regarding technical issues and Ubisoft's launcher. Despite these criticisms, players express deep affection for the game, often recalling fond memories and experiences. The mixed sentiment surrounding Ubisoft's practices somewhat offsets the game's numerous accolades.

Overall player feedback for Skull and Bones is highly polarized, with a significant divide between those who enjoy its naval combat and those who criticize its lack of depth and repetitive gameplay. Many players commend the ship mechanics and visuals, but numerous others express disappointment due to glitches, limited content, and unmet expectations compared to previous Ubisoft titles.

The feedback for 'Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii' reveals a largely positive player experience, with many praising its fun gameplay, humor, and engaging side content. However, there are notable criticisms regarding the story quality and ship combat mechanics, leaving some players feeling disappointed. Overall, players appreciate the goofiness and adventurous atmosphere of the game, although opinions vary significantly on how it fits within the Yakuza series.

Overall, the feedback on Raft is predominantly positive, especially highlighting the enjoyable multiplayer experience and crafting mechanics. Many players appreciate the satisfying progression from a small raft to a sprawling floating home, though some express disappointment regarding the late-game pacing and story elements.

Overall, player feedback for DREDGE is highly positive, with many praising its unique blend of fishing mechanics and Lovecraftian horror elements, as well as its atmosphere and art style. However, some reviews express dissatisfaction with the pacing and narrative depth, particularly regarding the fetch quests and the perceived shortcomings of the DLC. Despite the mixed feelings about certain gameplay aspects, the majority of players recommend the game for its engaging design and visuals.

Overall, player feedback for No Man's Sky is divided, with many praising its vast exploration potential and continual updates, while a significant number criticize repetitive gameplay and technical issues. The game has seen a notable transformation from its rocky launch to a more content-rich experience, yet opinions vary widely regarding gameplay depth and enjoyment.

Players overwhelmingly praise 'Grounded' for its engaging gameplay, creative world design, and enjoyable multiplayer experience. Many find the game to be an excellent survival crafting title that effectively combines exploration, combat, and base-building mechanics, while the aesthetic and thematic elements have left a lasting positive impression. However, some users did note issues related to gameplay mechanics, such as combat clunkiness and the optimization and performance concerns, which slightly detract from an otherwise stellar experience.

Overall, players are overwhelmingly positive about Subnautica, praising its immersive world, engaging gameplay, and the blend of exploration and horror elements. However, some critiques point to challenges with resource management and pacing in the later stages of the game, particularly regarding grindiness. Despite these criticisms, the majority of feedback reflects a deep appreciation for the game's atmosphere, visuals, and storytelling.

Overall, player feedback for Sailing Era is largely positive, with many praising its engaging gameplay, nostalgic nods to classic games, and immersive exploration mechanics. However, there are notable criticisms regarding technical issues, repetitiveness in gameplay, and translation quality, leading to a divided experience for some. While most players relish the game, a portion expresses frustration with its execution and mechanics.

Overall, players find "Sail Forth" to be an engaging and charming sailing game, praising its vibrant art style, enjoyable mechanics, and the fun of open-world exploration. While the majority of reviews highlight the relaxing nature of the game and its rewarding gameplay, some users express frustration over repetitive gameplay elements and control issues.

Player feedback on Rogue Waters is highly polarized, with many praising its engaging pirate theme and tactical combat while others criticize its numerous bugs, balance issues, and unfinished gameplay. Many feel that while it has potential, the game's execution and stability detract significantly from the overall enjoyment.

Player feedback on Windbound shows a divided reception, with some praising its beautiful visuals, sailing mechanics, and art style, while many express frustrations with gameplay mechanics, particularly regarding combat and inventory management. Although there are some positive reviews highlighting the game's exploration and engaging atmosphere, the overall sentiment reflects significant dissatisfaction with core gameplay elements.