Resident Evil 4 vs Resident Evil 3: Which Is Better?

Rowan Vale avatarRowan ValeAI author personaReviewed by Ugur Saritepe
Comparisons
resident evil 4resident evil 3resident evil remakesurvival horrorcapcomgame comparisonps5 horror games
Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4

Winner
RESIDENT EVIL 3

RESIDENT EVIL 3

VS
Resident Evil 4 is the better buy of the two Capcom remakes, and it is not especially close. It wins five of the eight categories here, including world, combat, story and value, and at the same 39.99 EUR on Steam it gives you about 20 hours of campaign against Resident Evil 3's 7.5. Our players agree: 4.74 out of 5 from 144,667 ratings, filed as great, against 4.41 from 81,225, filed as mixed. Resident Evil 3 is still worth it for the right reader. It is the tighter survival horror run, with a dodge players love and the only online mode of the pair.

Verdict

Resident Evil 4 wins five categories to two, with one draw, and it is the clearer win of any Resident Evil remake pairing we have run. Our players rate it 4.74 out of 5 from 144,667 ratings and file it as great; Resident Evil 3 sits at 4.41 from 81,225 and is filed as mixed, almost entirely over its length and the content it cut. Resident Evil 3 keeps the tighter survival pressure and the only online mode of the pair.

  • Play Resident Evil 4 if you want the long campaign, a varied world to move through and combat built to be fought in rather than avoided.
  • Play RESIDENT EVIL 3 if you want a short, tense survival horror run you can finish in a weekend, with a stalker on your heels and Jill Valentine in the lead.

Scoreboard

Resident Evil 4 wins 5, RESIDENT EVIL 3 wins 2, 1 draw

At a glance

Resident Evil 4RESIDENT EVIL 3
ReleasedMarch 2023March 2020
PlatformsPlayStation 4, PC, iOS, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series S/XPlayStation 5, Xbox Series S/X, PC, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Xbox One
Length20 h main, 43 h complete8 h main, 18 h complete
Player rating4.74 / 5 (144,667)higher4.41 / 5 (81,225)
Critic scoren/a80 / 100
Co-op and multiplayerSingle playerSingle player, Multiplayer
DLC4 DLC5 DLC
GenresHorror, Adventure, ActionAdventure, Action
Lead characterLeon S. KennedyJill Valentine
SettingA rural European village, six years after Raccoon CityRaccoon City during the outbreak
Steam price, November 202639.99 EUR39.99 EUR
Extra mode in the boxNone onlineResident Evil Resistance, 1 vs 4 online
Best forA long action-horror campaign worth the full priceA short survival horror run with a relentless stalker
Catalogue data from Game-Scout. A check marks the higher player or critic score; it does not count toward the scoreboard.

Should you play Resident Evil 3 before Resident Evil 4?

You can, but you do not need to. Resident Evil 3 follows Jill Valentine through the fall of Raccoon City, and Resident Evil 4 opens six years after that disaster with Leon S. Kennedy, a different lead, on a different continent, against a different threat. The stories touch only through the city they both leave behind.

  • Story order: Resident Evil 3 comes first, alongside Resident Evil 2.
  • Feel order: playing the short, scarce Resident Evil 3 first makes Resident Evil 4's arsenal land harder. The Steam thread on the three remakes calls one survival horror and the other survival action.
  • One purchase only: Resident Evil 4. Same price, more than twice the campaign.

World and exploration: Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4, World and exploration
Screenshot: Capcom U.S.A., Inc.

Resident Evil 4, and Resident Evil 3's own players hand it the category. Lack of environmental exploration and a campaign perceived as more linear and scripted are two of the five stored complaints about the 2020 remake, and cut features and content from the original sits right beside them. Its Raccoon City is beautiful while it lasts, but it is a corridor through a city rather than a city. Resident Evil 4 moves from a village to a castle to an island, and our catalogue logs exploration and puzzle-solving for it alongside stealth. IGN's review calls its Spanish countryside substantially more sinister than the original's. One game is a route with a few side rooms. The other is a journey with places worth getting lost in.

Combat and gameplay: Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4, Combat and gameplay
Screenshot: Capcom U.S.A., Inc.

Resident Evil 4, though Resident Evil 3 has the one move people still bring up. A satisfying dodge mechanic is in Resident Evil 3's stored player praise, and the Steam thread comparing all three remakes says the dodge roll feels great. Resident Evil 4 simply has more to work with: our catalogue logs melee, ranged combat, stealth and quick-time events for it, and engaging gameplay mechanics and smooth combat is its stored praise. That same thread ranks Resident Evil 4 first because its ammo economy, parry and melee attacks work together, so you keep adjusting position and tactics mid-fight. Resident Evil 3 asks you to survive an encounter. Resident Evil 4 asks you to win it, and gives you the tools.

Story and characters: Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4, Story and characters
Screenshot: Capcom U.S.A., Inc.

Resident Evil 4, but not because Resident Evil 3's cast is weak. Engaging character design and connection to the story is stored praise for the remake, and its reviews single out Jill Valentine and Carlos by name. The problem is how much story there is around them: disappointing story depth compared to the original is one of its stored complaints, and numerous cut features and content from the original is another, so Nemesis, the weapon Umbrella sends after Jill, chases her through a shorter story than players expected. Resident Evil 4's stored praise reads strong character development and storyline tweaks, with the faithfulness complaint that some changes diverge too much from the original. Leon's rescue of the president's daughter has the space to build. Jill's escape from Raccoon City ends just as it gets going.

Difficulty: RESIDENT EVIL 3

RESIDENT EVIL 3, Difficulty
Screenshot: Capcom U.S.A., Inc.

Resident Evil 3, as the game where the pressure is the design. The Steam thread on the three remakes draws the line clearly: in Resident Evil 2 and 3 enemies are resource dumps that force you to decide what to spend, while in Resident Evil 4 they are there to be fought, and you get something back for fighting them. It adds that Resident Evil 3 leans further toward action than Resident Evil 2 but keeps enough of that scarcity to stay interesting. Resident Evil 4 carries a difficulty complaint of its own, that certain gameplay elements feel artificially difficult, which is a different thing from tension. If you want to feel short of bullets with something heavy walking behind you, Resident Evil 3 is the harder sell on your nerves.

Visuals and performance: Draw

RESIDENT EVIL 3, Visuals and performance
Screenshot: Capcom U.S.A., Inc.

A draw, and the stored player praise is almost word for word on both sides. Incredible graphics and atmospheric design leads Resident Evil 4's list; high-quality graphics and aesthetics sits in Resident Evil 3's. Both have a PS5 version in our catalogue, so the gap people expect from three years between them is not one players report. Where they part is on performance. Graphical or performance issues on various setups is a stored complaint for Resident Evil 4, and Resident Evil 3 has no matching complaint at all, so the older, smaller game is the cleaner technical experience. Resident Evil 4 has the more striking places to look at. Resident Evil 3 runs them more smoothly.

Length and value: Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4, Length and value
Screenshot: Capcom U.S.A., Inc.

Resident Evil 4, and this is the widest gap on the page. Our catalogue logs a normal run of about 20 hours for Resident Evil 4 against about 7.5 for Resident Evil 3, and a full clear of about 43 hours against 18. On Steam in November 2026 both list at 39.99 EUR, so the same money buys well over twice the campaign. Resident Evil 3's leading stored complaint is the playtime, significantly shorter than the original, followed by the cut features and content, and those two are what pull its sentiment to mixed. Neither game is on a PS Plus tier in our availability data. The r/residentevil thread asking which of the two to buy for one price is the question this category answers.

Replayability and builds: Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4, Replayability and builds
Screenshot: Capcom U.S.A., Inc.

Resident Evil 4, though Resident Evil 3 is built for repeat runs too. Game Rant points to the remake's shop, where points earned by completing in-game challenges buy items for the next playthrough, and a seven-hour campaign is an easy one to run again. Players are still less warm about it: one poster in the Steam thread on the three remakes calls Resident Evil 3 a good game, just not as fun to replay. Resident Evil 4's stored praise is high replay value due to various modes and challenges, and its combat is the reason a second run feels new rather than familiar. A short game you can repeat is not the same as a game you want to.

Co-op and multiplayer: RESIDENT EVIL 3

RESIDENT EVIL 3, Co-op and multiplayer
Screenshot: Capcom U.S.A., Inc.

Resident Evil 3, because it is the only one of the two with any. Our catalogue lists single player and multiplayer modes for it, and the PlayStation Store bundle includes Resident Evil Resistance, a separate one versus four online game in which four survivors face off against a Mastermind. The Steam store lists online player versus player for Resident Evil 3; Resident Evil 4 lists single player only, and our catalogue records no co-op or multiplayer for it. Resistance is a side game, not a co-op campaign, and nothing in Resident Evil 3's stored praise is about it. If playing with other people matters at all, though, only one box has something for you.

What players say

Resident Evil 4

Praise

  • Incredible graphics and atmospheric design
  • Engaging gameplay mechanics and smooth combat
  • High replay value across modes and challenges

Complaints

  • Microtransactions
  • AI companion behaviour
  • Narrative changes that diverge from the original

RESIDENT EVIL 3

Praise

  • Polished gameplay mechanics
  • Jill and Carlos as characters
  • A satisfying dodge mechanic

Complaints

  • Much shorter than the original
  • Cut features and content from the original
  • A more linear, scripted campaign

The games

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Resident Evil 4 or Resident Evil 3?
Resident Evil 4. It wins five of eight categories here, and our players rate it 4.74 out of 5 from 144,667 ratings, filed as great, against Resident Evil 3's 4.41 from 81,225, filed as mixed. Resident Evil 3 wins on survival pressure and is the only one with an online mode.
Is Resident Evil 4 longer than Resident Evil 3?
Yes, by a wide margin. Our catalogue logs a normal run of about 20 hours for Resident Evil 4 against about 7.5 for Resident Evil 3, and a full clear of about 43 hours against 18. The short length is Resident Evil 3's leading stored player complaint.
Which is scarier, Resident Evil 4 or Resident Evil 3?
Players split on it. The Steam thread comparing the remakes calls Resident Evil 3 survival horror and Resident Evil 4 survival action, since Resident Evil 3 keeps you short on supplies. Yet an r/residentevil thread on exactly this question names Resident Evil 4 the scarier of the two.
Is Resident Evil 3 worth it after Resident Evil 4?
Yes, if you want more of the Raccoon City survival horror and accept that it is short. At 39.99 EUR on Steam it costs the same as Resident Evil 4 for a third of the campaign, so it is the better buy on sale. Its stored praise is polished gameplay, Jill and Carlos, and the dodge.
Do you need to play Resident Evil 3 before Resident Evil 4?
No. Resident Evil 4 is set six years after Raccoon City with a different lead, Leon S. Kennedy, and explains everything it needs. Resident Evil 3 comes first in story order, so play it first if you want the series in sequence.
Does Resident Evil 3 have multiplayer?
Yes, through Resident Evil Resistance, a separate one versus four online game bundled with it, where four survivors face a Mastermind. The campaign itself is single player. Resident Evil 4 has no online mode in our catalogue or on its Steam page.

Sources

Related Articles