- DREDGE
Best overall★ Overwhelmingly Positive (96%)PS Plus Extra
Fishing sim structure where the catch pays for upgrades and the night sea supplies the horror.
- SOMA
Best for existential dread★ Overwhelmingly Positive (96%)
First-person underwater sci-fi horror built around a philosophical question rather than combat.
- Darkest Dungeon
Best eldritch roguelike★ Very Positive (92%)
Turn-based party roguelike where stress and afflictions matter more than hit points.
- SIGNALIS
Best survival horror★ Overwhelmingly Positive (97%)
Fixed-inventory survival horror in a retro sci-fi setting with a deliberately cryptic plot.
- Look Outside
Best recent release★ Overwhelmingly Positive (98%)
Survival RPG confined to one apartment block, driven by a rule you can break at any moment.
- WORLD OF HORROR
Best for Junji Ito fans★ Very Positive (90%)
One-bit pixel mystery roguelite that reshuffles its cases, drawn in Junji Ito's style.
- Darkwood
Best atmosphere★ Very Positive (95%)
Top-down survival horror split between daytime scavenging and nightly house defence.
- Sunless Sea: Zubmariner Edition
Best for exploration★ Very Positive (83%)
Text-heavy exploration of an underground ocean where every port carries its own story.
- Cultist Simulator
Best occult puzzle★ Mostly Positive (80%)
Card-based cult management with no tutorial, learned almost entirely through failed runs.
- Iron Lung
Best for one sitting★ Very Positive (92%)
One-hour submarine game played through a camera and a map, with no direct view outside.
- Fear & Hunger 2: Termina
Best eldritch RPG★ Overwhelmingly Positive (97%)
Three-day survival RPG with fourteen playable characters and permanent consequences.
- Lobotomy Corporation
Best management sim★ Very Positive (94%)
Facility management sim where containing abominations doubles as the narrative.
- Strange Antiquities
Best quiet occult work★ Overwhelmingly Positive (95%)
Object-identification puzzler solved with reference books, with no combat at all.
- The Children of Clay
Best short horror★ Overwhelmingly Positive (99%)
Ninety-minute stop-motion horror centred on studying artefacts pulled from a dig.
- Lost in Vivo
Best claustrophobic horror★ Very Positive (91%)
Retro first-person horror about claustrophobia, set in a steadily narrowing storm drain.
- CULTIC
Best cosmic horror shooter★ Overwhelmingly Positive (97%)
Retro boomer shooter with an eldritch plot, built around fast combat and hidden secrets.
- Scarlet Hollow
Best writing★ Overwhelmingly Positive (98%)
Choice-driven visual novel where character traits rewrite conversations, releasing in chapters.
- Sucker for Love: First Date
Best comedic take★ Overwhelmingly Positive (98%)
Short visual novel that plays a ritual romance with an eldritch god for comedy.
- The Consuming Shadow
Best for replayability★ Very Positive (95%)
Procedural roguelite where you deduce which Ancient is arriving from scattered clues.
- SKALD: Against the Black Priory
Best retro CRPG★ Very Positive (94%)
Party-based retro CRPG with hand-written prose and a Lovecraftian coastal setting.