Game-Scout Logo
Game-Scout

Best Wrestling Games

The best wrestling game on PS5 and PS4 right now is WWE 2K25, with its 300-plus roster and deep creation suite, followed by the hardcore simulation of Fire Pro Wrestling World and the retro arcade throwback RetroMania Wrestling. This list ranks only wrestling games you can actually buy and play today, from mainline sims to arcade brawlers and a full turn-based wrestling RPG, weighed against what players actually say rather than nostalgia for older consoles.

How we rank games

Updated Aug 18, 2026

Top Picks

WWE 2K25
#1 Pick

WWE 2K25

★ 3.9Mixed
FIRE PRO WRESTLING WORLD
#2

FIRE PRO WRESTLING WORLD

★ 4.3Great
RETROMANIA WRESTLING
#3

RETROMANIA WRESTLING

★ 4.3Mixed

Discover Games

6 games found

1WWE 2K25
Best overall

WWE 2K25

3.9(16,424)2025
PS+ ExtraPS Plus ExtraESRB Teenmodern
MixedReview analysis

Overall, player feedback for WWE 2K25 is largely positive, with many praising its graphics and gameplay while highlighting concerns over gameplay balance and technical issues. Despite a significant portion of reviewers expressing enthusiasm about the game, there are notable criticisms regarding bugs and lack of content updates.

Why it's here: The genre flagship and the obvious starting point: a 300-plus roster, the deep MyRISE and MyGM modes, and the series best-looking presentation yet, with intergender matches and chain wrestling back in the fold. Reviews call the gameplay fun and the creation suite superb, but flag balance problems, occasional crashes, and thin post-launch content. If you want the most complete WWE package on PS5, this is it, though MyFaction grinders should temper their expectations.

See full details
2FIRE PRO WRESTLING WORLD
Best for creators

FIRE PRO WRESTLING WORLD

4.3(1,700)2018
ESRB Teen
GreatReview analysis

Overall player feedback for Fire Pro Wrestling World is overwhelmingly positive, with players praising its extensive customization options, retro graphics, and engaging gameplay mechanics. However, some players found its learning curve and reliance on DLC for full enjoyment to be significant drawbacks.

Why it's here: The connoisseur pick, and the highest-rated wrestling game here. Its grid-timing grappling and famously deep editor let you build wrestlers, promotions, and rulesets that no licensed title can match, backed by a modding community that keeps the roster endless. Players warn of a steep learning curve, cluttered menus, and features locked behind paid DLC. Newcomers should expect to study, but anyone who wants to design their own promotion will find nothing else like it.

See full details
3RETROMANIA WRESTLING
Best retro throwback

RETROMANIA WRESTLING

4.3(398)2021
Co-op: 4ESRB Teen
MixedReview analysis

Overall player feedback for RetroMania Wrestling is mixed, reflecting strong nostalgia and admiration for its homage to classic wrestling games, while simultaneously expressing significant frustrations regarding its limited roster, lack of content, and grappling mechanics. Many players enjoy the gameplay and visuals, but a notable number feel disappointed about the game's fulfillment of expectations and its pricing.

Why it's here: A love letter to WWF WrestleFest and the arcade era, built by developers who clearly grew up on it. The pixel art and pick-up-and-play grappling land the nostalgia, and steady updates have added fixes. Reviews are split: fans enjoy the simple fun, but many call the roster thin and the price steep for the content, with grappling that can feel unresponsive. Best for arcade-wrestling purists rather than anyone chasing a modern career mode.

See full details
4WrestleQuest
Best for RPG fans

WrestleQuest

3.7(196)2023
ESRB Everyone 10+
MixedReview analysis

Overall, player feedback for WrestleQuest is highly polarized, with many expressing enjoyment for the nostalgic wrestling theme, humor, and engaging graphics, while encountering significant frustrations with frequent bugs, a repetitive combat system, and pacing issues. Players who are fans of both wrestling and classic turn-based RPGs tend to enjoy the game, while others criticize it for its numerous technical issues and lack of depth in gameplay.

Why it's here: The oddball of the list: a turn-based RPG that runs on wrestling-figure fantasy, packed with in-jokes, bright pixel art, and cameo-heavy writing. When it clicks for fans of both wrestling and classic JRPGs, the humor and premise carry it. Reviews are polarized, though, calling out game-breaking bugs, repetitive combat, and backtracking that saps the pacing. Worth it if the RPG angle excites you more than the ring itself, but pure wrestling fans should look elsewhere.

See full details
5AEW: Fight Forever

AEW: Fight Forever

2.6(10,982)2023
PS+ TrialCo-op: 2PS Plus PremiumESRB Teenmodern
MixedReview analysis

Player feedback for AEW: Fight Forever reveals a polarized sentiment, with many fans praising its nostalgic arcade-style gameplay reminiscent of classic wrestling games, while criticism often focuses on its lack of content and frustrating game mechanics. Overall, players find it enjoyable as a casual experience, particularly when acquired at a discounted price, though significant issues prevent it from being universally recommended.

Why it's here: The big-budget AEW alternative to 2K, chasing the fast arcade No Mercy feel with real AEW stars and goofy mini-games. In multiplayer it delivers exactly that nostalgic couch-brawl energy. But it is the lowest-rated pick here for a reason: reviews hammer the thin career mode, limited match types and customization, and clunky mechanics. Recommended for AEW diehards and party sessions, ideally on sale, rather than as a solo main course.

See full details
6Action Arcade Wrestling
Best for newcomers

Action Arcade Wrestling

4.0(174)2021
ESRB Teen
MixedReview analysis

Overall player feedback indicates that "Action Arcade Wrestling" is a fun and entertaining arcade-style game with a strong emphasis on community-created content. However, many players express disappointment with the lack of depth, modes, and some persistent bugs affecting gameplay.

Why it's here: The most approachable pick: a lightweight arcade wrestler built around simple controls and a huge library of community-created wrestlers you can download for free. It is easy to jump into and cheap fun for quick matches. Reviews are fond of it but consistent about the limits: no real campaign or story modes, repetitive AI, and recurring bugs. A solid low-commitment entry point or content sandbox, as long as you are not expecting career-mode depth.

See full details

About Wrestling Games

Wrestling games split into several distinct styles, and this list spans all of them rather than repeating one franchise. The licensed mainline sim (WWE 2K25) leads, alongside the deep create-a-wrestler simulator with an endless modding community (Fire Pro Wrestling World), the arcade-era throwback (RetroMania Wrestling), the turn-based wrestling RPG (WrestleQuest), the big AEW alternative (AEW: Fight Forever), and the accessible pick-up-and-play arcade wrestler (Action Arcade Wrestling). Every game here is available on PS5 or PS4, so nothing on the ranking is a retro title stranded on hardware you no longer own. For every game on this list, we read and summarized player reviews from Steam and the PlayStation Store into what players consistently praise and consistently complain about, then ranked accordingly.

Curated by Ugur Saritepe. Rankings weigh aggregated player ratings and review sentiment collected from Steam and the PlayStation Store, with catalogue data from IGDB. How we rankPlayStation StoreSteamIGDB

Explore More Gaming Categories

Best Wrestling Games Compared

  • WWE 2K25
    Best overall★ 3.88 / 5PS Plus Extra

    The mainline licensed WWE sim with a 300-plus roster, MyRISE and MyGM modes, and the series' deepest creation suite.

  • FIRE PRO WRESTLING WORLD
    Best for creators★ 4.25 / 5

    Grid-timing grappling and a legendary editor for building custom wrestlers, promotions and rulesets, backed by heavy modding.

  • RETROMANIA WRESTLING
    Best retro throwback★ 4.31 / 5

    A pixel-art homage to WWF WrestleFest with simple arcade grappling built for quick, nostalgic matches.

  • WrestleQuest
    Best for RPG fans★ 3.68 / 5

    A turn-based RPG that swaps ring simulation for wrestling-figure fantasy, cameo-heavy writing and JRPG combat.

  • AEW: Fight Forever
    ★ 2.56 / 5PS Plus Premium

    The AEW-licensed arcade brawler chasing an N64 No Mercy feel, strongest in local multiplayer party sessions.

  • Action Arcade Wrestling
    Best for newcomers★ 4.04 / 5

    A lightweight arcade wrestler with a large library of free community-created wrestlers to download and fight.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best wrestling game on PS5 and PS4?
WWE 2K25 is the best all-around wrestling game available on PS5 and PS4, thanks to its 300-plus roster and the series' deepest creation suite. For players who want total control over wrestlers and rules, Fire Pro Wrestling World is the hardcore simulation pick, while RetroMania Wrestling is the choice for arcade-era nostalgia.
Is WWE 2K25 good?
WWE 2K25 reviews are mixed-to-positive. Players consistently praise the visuals, the MyRISE and MyGM modes and the community creation tools, but the recurring complaints in Steam and PlayStation Store reviews are gameplay balance issues, occasional crashes and thin post-launch content. It is the most complete WWE package on this list, with caveats for anyone chasing MyFaction rewards.
What is the best wrestling game that isn't WWE?
AEW: Fight Forever is the largest non-WWE wrestling game on PS5 and PS4, built around a fast arcade feel with real AEW stars, though its reviews are the most mixed on this list. Fire Pro Wrestling World and RetroMania Wrestling are the stronger-reviewed non-WWE picks, for hardcore simulation and retro-arcade fans respectively.
Are there any wrestling games on PS Plus?
Yes. WWE 2K25 is included in the PS Plus Extra and Premium game catalogue, and AEW: Fight Forever is available through PS Plus Premium. The other picks on this list, including Fire Pro Wrestling World, RetroMania Wrestling and WrestleQuest, are standard purchases rather than PS Plus catalogue titles.
Is there a wrestling RPG?
Yes. WrestleQuest is a turn-based RPG built on wrestling-figure fantasy, mixing classic JRPG combat with wrestling storylines and humor. Reviews are polarized, praising the premise and writing while flagging bugs and repetitive combat, so it suits players who love both wrestling and old-school RPGs more than pure ring action.
What is the best wrestling game for beginners?
Action Arcade Wrestling is the most beginner-friendly pick, with simple controls, a free library of community-created wrestlers and quick pick-up-and-play matches. RetroMania Wrestling is similarly accessible for arcade fans, while WWE 2K25 offers the most depth once you are ready for its fuller systems.

Was this helpful?